Can human life be meaningful? What does it mean to discuss life's meaning? What role does God play in a meaningful life? These questions frame a unique debate between two philosophers who have dedicated their careers to exploring life's meaning. Professors Thaddeus Metz and Joshua W. Seachris engage in a scholarly conversation, presenting and defending their distinct perspectives while addressing each other's objections in a lively dialog format. Seachris posits that life's meaning revolves around three interconnected concepts: mattering, purpose, and sense-making. He argues that a meaningful life manifests all three and that God enhances meaning in each area. In contrast, Metz suggests that discussions of life's meaning pertain to various properties, such as meriting pride, transcending one's animal nature, contributing to society, and authoring a life story. He believes many lives can be meaningful through intelligent, positive, and developmental pursuits, asserting that God is not necessary for an objective meaning aligned with human nature. Their engaging exchange offers insights that are accessible to students while also appealing to scholars interested in their new contributions.
